When a child struggles to engage in learning, finds a transition difficult or responds in an unexpected way, even experienced educators can find themselves wondering: “Am I responding in the right way?”
There can be many reasons why children experience difficulties at school. Developmental needs, relationships, SEND, family circumstances and previous experiences, including trauma, may all play a part.
Educators may not always know exactly why a child is struggling, but they can still consider what that child may need now.
Trauma-responsive practice means taking the possible impact of trauma into account alongside what else is known about the child: their development, communication, relationships, strengths, needs and wider circumstances.
The challenge is knowing how to respond when the answer isn’t immediately obvious. For staff to do that confidently, they need to feel able to ask questions, seek support and acknowledge when they’re unsure.
What does trauma-responsive practice look like when you're not sure what to try next?
An educator may understand how trauma can affect development and relationships and still be unsure about the best response in a particular situation.
Perhaps a strategy that usually helps has made little difference. Perhaps the child’s needs are not clear. Or perhaps several things could be contributing and it is difficult to know where to start.
For example, a pupil who finds it difficult to begin independent work may need additional guidance, reassurance, a different way to access the task or support with an underlying learning or communication need.
The same outward difficulty can have very different influences behind it, which is why it is important not to assume the cause.
Our new research with 690 education professionals suggests this is an area worth paying attention to.
Only 21% said their most substantial professional learning covered what to do when an initial response wasn't helping.
Being able to stop, think and talk something through with a colleague matters.
A member of staff should be able to say, “I'm not sure what this child needs” or “What I tried didn't help” and use that as the start of a useful professional conversation.
How colleagues and leaders respond in that moment matters too.
Three questions that can help
When something has not gone as expected, these questions can help staff think through what to do next.
What might this child need from me right now?
Think about what you already know about the child: their strengths, development, communication, relationships and current circumstances.
What might help them participate or engage? What can you appropriately do within your role?
What has helped so far?
Look back at what you have noticed already.
There may be particular relationships, routines, approaches or adjustments that have helped. Even a small change in engagement or connection can tell you something useful.
What could we try differently?
If the first response has not helped, consider what could change.
A colleague may notice something you have missed or know something about the child that changes your thinking. Agree a practical next step and come back to it afterwards to see what happened.
The aim is not to work backwards from a behaviour and try to identify a hidden cause. These questions keep attention on the child's current needs and what staff can appropriately do to support them.
The culture around staff matters too
Building a supportive culture doesn't necessarily mean introducing new initiatives or additional meetings.
It can start with what happens when an educator raises a concern, asks for advice or shares something that hasn't worked.
If staff feel they are expected to have an immediate answer, they may be less comfortable discussing uncertainty or seeking support from colleagues.
A question such as “What might this child need, and what could we try differently?” creates space to reflect on what is known about the child and agree a practical next step.
This does not mean lowering expectations or overlooking behaviour that needs addressing. It means maintaining appropriate boundaries and expectations while considering how best to support the child.
Over time, those conversations can help develop a more consistent approach across the setting, while reinforcing that responding to children's needs is a shared responsibility.
New research from Thrive
Understanding trauma is only the start.
Our new report, Understanding Trauma and Responding to Need, explores what helps educators use that understanding when a child's needs are unclear or the first response doesn't work.
Based on responses from 690 education professionals, it looks at professional learning, what happens after training, the support staff can draw on and the conditions they are working within.
The report launches next week.
Join our free webinar: Creating a Trauma-Responsive Culture
Monday 7 December | 4:00–4:45pm (GMT)
Join Dr Suzanne Zeedyk and Viv Trask-Hall as they draw on Thrive's latest research to explore five conditions that help staff respond with confidence.
Discover how school leaders can create environments that support professional curiosity, reflection and consistent, needs-responsive practice, with practical questions to help identify where your setting could focus next.
